Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Dampening Question
Wheels-InMotion > Chassis Dynamics Forums > Modifications
TDIPLC
This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif
Bazza
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 12:42 PM) *
This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif


what about us mere mortals wink.gif

when you say three way adjustable dampers, do you mean height and damping adjustable,
i am using the D2`s on the starlet, and they have an infinate amount of different adjustments, but are track orientated, which means although the can be adjusted for road use they are allways a bit stiff and therefore a bit uncomfortable for everyday road use
presuming road orientated would have a more comfortable ride, but be less suitable for track use
is it possible to have the best of both worlds !!
TDIPLC
QUOTE (Bazza @ May 17 2006, 01:41 PM) *
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 12:42 PM) *

This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif


what about us mere mortals wink.gif

when you say three way adjustable dampers, do you mean height and damping adjustable,
i am using the D2`s on the starlet, and they have an infinate amount of different adjustments, but are track orientated, which means although the can be adjusted for road use they are allways a bit stiff and therefore a bit uncomfortable for everyday road use
presuming road orientated would have a more comfortable ride, but be less suitable for track use
is it possible to have the best of both worlds !!


Three way (or even better four way) adjustable damping is perfect for us mere mortals smile.gif

Let me explain (tapping chalk on blackboard) if I may?
A two way adjustable damper allows you to adjust both bump (compression) and rebound (extension) rates to optimise handling to suit the application in normal use. That's fine, but what happens when the wheel hits a bump or pot hole? The car is sent completely off line because it's applying the same bump/rebound setting to a very fast change in cirumstances as is to it's normal operating conditions.

What 3 and 4 way adjustable dampers allow you to do is to also set the bump and rebound for rapid reactions as well as for the normal slow reacting conditions.

I'm not very good at explaining things so I hope that made sense unsure.gif

Clearly, there is a layer of cost attached to this so it's not cheap, but anyone that has driven a car with good and bad suspension will know that it's money well spent.
Tony
Is this a coil over oil application or just a damper only configuration.
TDIPLC
QUOTE (Tony @ May 17 2006, 03:25 PM) *
Is this a coil over oil application or just a damper only configuration.


It can be either. It can also be gas or oil.

The application we are working on at the moment is a coil over system. Exciting times smile.gif
Bazza
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 02:14 PM) *
QUOTE (Bazza @ May 17 2006, 01:41 PM) *

QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 12:42 PM) *

This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif


what about us mere mortals wink.gif

when you say three way adjustable dampers, do you mean height and damping adjustable,
i am using the D2`s on the starlet, and they have an infinate amount of different adjustments, but are track orientated, which means although the can be adjusted for road use they are allways a bit stiff and therefore a bit uncomfortable for everyday road use
presuming road orientated would have a more comfortable ride, but be less suitable for track use
is it possible to have the best of both worlds !!


Three way (or even better four way) adjustable damping is perfect for us mere mortals smile.gif

Let me explain (tapping chalk on blackboard) if I may?
A two way adjustable damper allows you to adjust both bump (compression) and rebound (extension) rates to optimise handling to suit the application in normal use. That's fine, but what happens when the wheel hits a bump or pot hole? The car is sent completely off line because it's applying the same bump/rebound setting to a very fast change in cirumstances as is to it's normal operating conditions.

What 3 and 4 way adjustable dampers allow you to do is to also set the bump and rebound for rapid reactions as well as for the normal slow reacting conditions.

I'm not very good at explaining things so I hope that made sense unsure.gif

Clearly, there is a layer of cost attached to this so it's not cheap, but anyone that has driven a car with good and bad suspension will know that it's money well spent.


tsk tsk mark, its whiteboards now !, how long is it since you were at school laugh.gif

if i am understanding this right

normally when three way adjustment is mentioned it is concerning for example a "coilover"
what you are saying is that your three way adjustment is solely concerning the damper
sounds very complex
but also sounds like you can have the best of both worlds

i will sit back and listen now smile.gif
TDIPLC
QUOTE (Bazza @ May 17 2006, 04:56 PM) *
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 02:14 PM) *

QUOTE (Bazza @ May 17 2006, 01:41 PM) *

QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 12:42 PM) *

This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif


what about us mere mortals wink.gif

when you say three way adjustable dampers, do you mean height and damping adjustable,
i am using the D2`s on the starlet, and they have an infinate amount of different adjustments, but are track orientated, which means although the can be adjusted for road use they are allways a bit stiff and therefore a bit uncomfortable for everyday road use
presuming road orientated would have a more comfortable ride, but be less suitable for track use
is it possible to have the best of both worlds !!


Three way (or even better four way) adjustable damping is perfect for us mere mortals smile.gif

Let me explain (tapping chalk on blackboard) if I may?
A two way adjustable damper allows you to adjust both bump (compression) and rebound (extension) rates to optimise handling to suit the application in normal use. That's fine, but what happens when the wheel hits a bump or pot hole? The car is sent completely off line because it's applying the same bump/rebound setting to a very fast change in cirumstances as is to it's normal operating conditions.

What 3 and 4 way adjustable dampers allow you to do is to also set the bump and rebound for rapid reactions as well as for the normal slow reacting conditions.

I'm not very good at explaining things so I hope that made sense unsure.gif

Clearly, there is a layer of cost attached to this so it's not cheap, but anyone that has driven a car with good and bad suspension will know that it's money well spent.


tsk tsk mark, its whiteboards now !, how long is it since you were at school laugh.gif

if i am understanding this right

normally when three way adjustment is mentioned it is concerning for example a "coilover"
what you are saying is that your three way adjustment is solely concerning the damper
sounds very complex
but also sounds like you can have the best of both worlds

i will sit back and listen now smile.gif


Blimey I thought blackboards were modern compared to the parchment and quill that I had when I was at school blink.gif

Three and four way adjustable shocks just refers the damping, and is considerably better that 1 or 2 way smile.gif
Tony
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 02:41 PM) *
QUOTE (Tony @ May 17 2006, 03:25 PM) *

Is this a coil over oil application or just a damper only configuration.


It can be either. It can also be gas or oil.

The application we are working on at the moment is a coil over system. Exciting times smile.gif

Exciting times indeed.... were is your intended market. Road/Track/Race?..... Is the evolution marque specific or global in fitment?.... Also are there additional compliments required to assist or evolve the new damper system.
scorps
What is the weight of these,are they lighter than stock?

Will they have a cooling reservoir?

Can they be reshimed by the owner or will they have to go back to you?

Sorry for all the questions,but people will ask these biggrin.gif

Your 2 seconds a lap quicker?.............wet/dry same curcuit or different?

Hope you've got plenty of chalk left biggrin.gif biggrin.gif
jon
I've had a fair bit of fun playing with 2 way damping though currently run 1 for track use.

I can see the benefit of 3 way on bad surface but a smooth track? I guess she'll ride the curbs a lot better...

I'm certianly going to follow this with interest (not least because my HAs are getting past their best)
TDIPLC
QUOTE (scorps @ May 17 2006, 10:27 PM) *
What is the weight of these,are they lighter than stock?

Will they have a cooling reservoir?

Can they be reshimed by the owner or will they have to go back to you?

Sorry for all the questions,but people will ask these biggrin.gif

Your 2 seconds a lap quicker?.............wet/dry same curcuit or different?

Hope you've got plenty of chalk left biggrin.gif biggrin.gif


There's not generally a significant weight difference between 2 and 3 way adjustables. Where weight is an issue, they can be made in aluminium but that is more expensive.

The project we are working on at he moment is not Japanese related - it's a high value British car whose owners are generally more quality than cost conscious.

The shocks will have to be returned to the manufacturer for revalving.

The issue regarding the reservoir will probably vary according to the application, but a separate reservoir is preferable.

Regarding the 2 secs per lap, it's exacty the same conditions except for changing the shocks.




QUOTE (jon @ May 17 2006, 11:19 PM) *
I can see the benefit of 3 way on bad surface but a smooth track? I guess she'll ride the curbs a lot better...


Exactly biggrin.gif

When a car is set up using one or two way damping (or no adjustment at all), there is a big compromise as it must be set for adequate performance beween slow and fast reacting damping. If it was optimised for slow reacting damping (which most set ups are) the car is unbalanced when a bump or dip is encountered. Conversely, if it is optimised for fast reacting damping, the car will be unstable under smooth conditions.

Imagine a scenario where both conditions can be optimised - thats 3 and 4 way adjustable biggrin.gif

My chalk is running out now smile.gif
jon
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 18 2006, 09:24 AM) *
Imagine a scenario where both conditions can be optimised biggrin.gif


Now you're just talking dirty...
TDIPLC
QUOTE (jon @ May 18 2006, 09:41 AM) *
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 18 2006, 09:24 AM) *

Imagine a scenario where both conditions can be optimised biggrin.gif


Now you're just talking dirty...


Yup, all great thing begin with fantasizing wink.gif
Tony
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 18 2006, 08:24 AM) *
QUOTE (scorps @ May 17 2006, 10:27 PM) *

What is the weight of these,are they lighter than stock?

Will they have a cooling reservoir?

Can they be reshimed by the owner or will they have to go back to you?

Sorry for all the questions,but people will ask these biggrin.gif

Your 2 seconds a lap quicker?.............wet/dry same curcuit or different?

Hope you've got plenty of chalk left biggrin.gif biggrin.gif


There's not generally a significant weight difference between 2 and 3 way adjustables. Where weight is an issue, they can be made in aluminium but that is more expensive.

The project we are working on at he moment is not Japanese related - it's a high value British car whose owners are generally more quality than cost conscious.

The shocks will have to be returned to the manufacturer for revalving.

The issue regarding the reservoir will probably vary according to the application, but a separate reservoir is preferable.

Regarding the 2 secs per lap, it's exacty the same conditions except for changing the shocks.




QUOTE (jon @ May 17 2006, 11:19 PM) *
I can see the benefit of 3 way on bad surface but a smooth track? I guess she'll ride the curbs a lot better...


Exactly biggrin.gif

When a car is set up using one or two way damping (or no adjustment at all), there is a big compromise as it must be set for adequate performance beween slow and fast reacting damping. If it was optimised for slow reacting damping (which most set ups are) the car is unbalanced when a bump or dip is encountered. Conversely, if it is optimised for fast reacting damping, the car will be unstable under smooth conditions.

Imagine a scenario where both conditions can be optimised - thats 3 and 4 way adjustable biggrin.gif

My chalk is running out now smile.gif

I like this scenario... Weigh plates and 'pull downs' would add an interesting evolution i feel... Has this been explored.. If not can wim assist if only in data analysis furthering development.
TDIPLC
QUOTE (Tony @ May 29 2006, 06:49 PM) *
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 18 2006, 08:24 AM) *

QUOTE (scorps @ May 17 2006, 10:27 PM) *

What is the weight of these,are they lighter than stock?

Will they have a cooling reservoir?

Can they be reshimed by the owner or will they have to go back to you?

Sorry for all the questions,but people will ask these biggrin.gif

Your 2 seconds a lap quicker?.............wet/dry same curcuit or different?

Hope you've got plenty of chalk left biggrin.gif biggrin.gif


There's not generally a significant weight difference between 2 and 3 way adjustables. Where weight is an issue, they can be made in aluminium but that is more expensive.

The project we are working on at he moment is not Japanese related - it's a high value British car whose owners are generally more quality than cost conscious.

The shocks will have to be returned to the manufacturer for revalving.

The issue regarding the reservoir will probably vary according to the application, but a separate reservoir is preferable.

Regarding the 2 secs per lap, it's exacty the same conditions except for changing the shocks.




QUOTE (jon @ May 17 2006, 11:19 PM) *
I can see the benefit of 3 way on bad surface but a smooth track? I guess she'll ride the curbs a lot better...


Exactly biggrin.gif

When a car is set up using one or two way damping (or no adjustment at all), there is a big compromise as it must be set for adequate performance beween slow and fast reacting damping. If it was optimised for slow reacting damping (which most set ups are) the car is unbalanced when a bump or dip is encountered. Conversely, if it is optimised for fast reacting damping, the car will be unstable under smooth conditions.

Imagine a scenario where both conditions can be optimised - thats 3 and 4 way adjustable biggrin.gif

My chalk is running out now smile.gif

I like this scenario... Weigh plates and 'pull downs' would add an interesting evolution i feel... Has this been explored.. If not can wim assist if only in data analysis furthering development.



I suspect that your input would be truly essential Tony smile.gif
Tony
Quote:TDIPLC
Not at STS unfortunately.... All my math is either in my head or if complicated a few hours with the old pen and paper... Geometry in truth should be as visible as a dyno.. Add every modification to the equation including Dampening/Coil Reaction then an image should be visible though the fog.... But new evolution like this dampening set-up invites constructive/destructive argument.. For Development between fields..... That's a good thing biggrin.gif
TDIPLC
QUOTE (Tony @ May 29 2006, 07:43 PM) *
Quote:TDIPLC
Not at STS unfortunately.... All my math is either in my head or if complicated a few hours with the old pen and paper... Geometry in truth should be as visible as a dyno.. Add every modification to the equation including Dampening/Coil Reaction then an image should be visible though the fog.... But new evolution like this dampening set-up invites constructive/destructive argument.. For Development between fields..... That's a good thing biggrin.gif


No doubt loosening the restrictions of your current incarceration will liberate a freedom of thought and actions, therefore your wisdom and knowledge in the field of geometry will be essential to us.
Tony
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 29 2006, 07:56 PM) *
QUOTE (Tony @ May 29 2006, 07:43 PM) *

Quote:TDIPLC
Not at STS unfortunately.... All my math is either in my head or if complicated a few hours with the old pen and paper... Geometry in truth should be as visible as a dyno.. Add every modification to the equation including Dampening/Coil Reaction then an image should be visible though the fog.... But new evolution like this dampening set-up invites constructive/destructive argument.. For Development between fields..... That's a good thing biggrin.gif


No doubt loosening the restrictions of your current incarceration will liberate a freedom of thought and actions, therefore your wisdom and knowledge in the field of geometry will be essential to us.

Excellent opportunity for evolution.... Proof is a foundation....Any takers in wim or TDIPLC Please keep us apprised
jon
wub.gif
Tony
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 29 2006, 07:56 PM) *
QUOTE (Tony @ May 29 2006, 07:43 PM) *

Quote:TDIPLC
Not at STS unfortunately.... All my math is either in my head or if complicated a few hours with the old pen and paper... Geometry in truth should be as visible as a dyno.. Add every modification to the equation including Dampening/Coil Reaction then an image should be visible though the fog.... But new evolution like this dampening set-up invites constructive/destructive argument.. For Development between fields..... That's a good thing biggrin.gif


No doubt loosening the restrictions of your current incarceration will liberate a freedom of thought and actions, therefore your wisdom and knowledge in the field of geometry will be essential to us.

My patience, opportunity is waning fast....My release may be premature...... Although my final destination still is not final?
Tony
QUOTE (jon @ May 29 2006, 08:23 PM) *
wub.gif


I recall a certain prominent company inviting a target car to 'evolve' for commercial reasons. And a 'ME, ME, 'ME' plea from a wanting recipient.... This marriage has become very visible...... unsure.gif

I would love to expand and assist your final stages mechanically for the race events, i assume you intend to advertise any 'sponsors' on the cars body, but unfortunately I lack the skill.... Maybe your near complete/ race ready example could fall under a similar wing..... who knows smile.gif
Tony
QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 01:14 PM) *
QUOTE (Bazza @ May 17 2006, 01:41 PM) *

QUOTE (TDIPLC @ May 17 2006, 12:42 PM) *

This one is for Tony and any other suspension Genii.

We are developing a new road orientated suspension kit for a car (secret squirrel at the moment) using 3 way adjustable dampers.

We have seen truly amazing results on the track using this system (2 seconds per lap), and was wondering if anyone has any thoughts on this concept or has tried it?

Thanks smile.gif


what about us mere mortals wink.gif

when you say three way adjustable dampers, do you mean height and damping adjustable,
i am using the D2`s on the starlet, and they have an infinate amount of different adjustments, but are track orientated, which means although the can be adjusted for road use they are allways a bit stiff and therefore a bit uncomfortable for everyday road use
presuming road orientated would have a more comfortable ride, but be less suitable for track use
is it possible to have the best of both worlds !!


Three way (or even better four way) adjustable damping is perfect for us mere mortals smile.gif

Let me explain (tapping chalk on blackboard) if I may?
A two way adjustable damper allows you to adjust both bump (compression) and rebound (extension) rates to optimise handling to suit the application in normal use. That's fine, but what happens when the wheel hits a bump or pot hole? The car is sent completely off line because it's applying the same bump/rebound setting to a very fast change in cirumstances as is to it's normal operating conditions.

What 3 and 4 way adjustable dampers allow you to do is to also set the bump and rebound for rapid reactions as well as for the normal slow reacting conditions.

I'm not very good at explaining things so I hope that made sense unsure.gif

Clearly, there is a layer of cost attached to this so it's not cheap, but anyone that has driven a car with good and bad suspension will know that it's money well spent.

How's the testing going?.....The Monroe Sensatrac tried a similar concept some years ago and failed, i believe because the 'passive' damper was sealed (no adjustment) as a result '3 and 4' was denied compromising the handling during the rapid requirements... Adjustable at the '3 & 4' stage reads very interesting.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.